I have a story to share. Let me explain. It is unavoidable and it is the truth that we won’t be liked by everyone we encounter in our life. In life there will always be people who try to thwart the progress of those that are spiritually advancing for various selfish reasons.
Some will treat us like a friend to our face, then lie, cheat and steal behind our back. Others will give us the best advice they have to offer and will do it in such a way that we’ll be convinced that they are right, even though they are very wrong, which will bring us much trouble. Still others will implant bad ideas in our head about ourselves or others, that were never our thoughts to begin with.
A particular sect of Tibetan Buddhism uses mantras as a spiritual protection, an aura of defense, if you will. What does it mean to use a mantra as a defense? It means having a protection from harm. You must be initiated into this practice of Yidams in person with a Guru from an authentic Vajrayana Buddhist lineage in order for them to work. It’s one of the highest yoga tantra practices. Yidam Practice is a way that leads to accomplishment and enlightenment. ‘Yi’ means Mind. ‘Dam’ means Committment. It is a ‘Mind Commitment.’
Oh sure you can recite the Yidam’s mantra if you learned it but without the teachings surrounding it and an understanding of the teaching, a true empowerment, you’re as good as useless with it. The majority of practicing Tibetan Buddhists do not practice this type of high yoga tantra as they’ve not been officially initiated.
Now as the story goes, in the late 19 century there was a great scholar who was accomplished with siddhis and who was a person that possessed supranormal perceptual states. Siddhis are typically defined as “a magical or spiritual powers for the control of self, others and the forces of nature.” Some might say it’s magic while others might say its being extremely adept at controlling the mind.
This scholarly monk was versed in Nyingmapa and had written a text about the Middle Path, about how to clear up some diversification points. As was normal for that time period the Tibetan Buddhists debated the teachings of Buddha holding all the authentic teachings valid.
In the debate about the Middle Path the debating monks first became very sad that this Nyingmapa scholar had defeated them with flying colors. Their sadness grew into hatred and once that happened they held wrong views. They decided they must perform a powerful puja to subdue him and convinced themselves that if they subjugated the Nyingmapa scholar that they would be protecting the Buddha’s holy teachings. Thus they set out like vultures to put him off by performing wrathful prayers and did perform these pujas. Unfortunately for them they had met with someone highly unsusual.
This Nyingmapa scholar remained normal, stayed healthy & happy. He did see a few inauspicious signs so was aware something was up.
Well, when the 13th Dalai Lama heard of what these monks had done he was so worried he sent his messenger to apologize for those monks. The Nyingmapa scholar was none other than Jamgon Ju Mipham Gyatso also known as “Mipham the Great.” (Mipham is considered to be one the three “omnscient” writers of the Nyingma tradition) When the messenger delivered the apology to Mipham Rinpoche he simply smiled & replied: “What those monks had performed was utmost powerful. It could crush a huge mountain into dust. If I have not assumed the Glorious Yamantaka form, I am dead by now.”
What happened to those monks who performed the pujas and wrathful prayers to subdue Mipham Rinpoche? Some committed suicide, some died of an illness, some went crazy, some had bad luck.
There is a lesson in what happened to these monks.
Tibetan Buddhism is divided into two major sectors, Sutra-yana and Vajra-yana and it consists of four schools : Nyingmapa, Kagyudpa, Gelugpa and Sakyapa. All practitioners from every school begin by studying sutras and basic philosophies and then slowly progress to Tantra.
Debating is a method adopted by them to sharpen one’s understanding of Buddhism teachings; while questioning others, one also examines one’s understanding. However, there is one major rule here that everyone must abide to, i.e. this is not a worldly debate, one should not grow hatred if one loses the debate and one should not be proud if he won. A wrong view can lead to one’s downfall therefore Vajrayana Buddhism emphasizes holding the RIGHT VIEW.
Guru Chokling Rinpoche described it in this way, “As Vajrayana practitioners, like a snake in bamboo, we can only go two directions: up or down.”The bottom line is: If one misses the objective of having debate, it is better not to have one at all.